I’m very pleased to publish the first case study from my Washington DC acupuncture practice. “Jennifer” is a 28-year-old patient who came to my office in April with lifelong insomnia, which had been getting worse in the past 6 months.
Read her case study to see how acupuncture, Chinese herbs, diet and exercise changes, and “sleep hygiene” adjustments helped her completely overcome her insomnia in 2 months.
When Jennifer first came into my office in April 2011, she reported a lifelong inability to sleep well. It regularly took her more than one hour to fall asleep, even when she was exhausted, and she would wake up multiple times each night. In addition, her sleep had always been light, and due to the lack of deep sleep, she woke up feeling lethargic, tired, and irritable. Her lack of sleep also negatively affected her energy levels during the day. Her facial skin color was pale, with an orange coloration under her eyes.
Her insomnia had been getting much worse over the past year, so she decided to seek acupuncture as a natural way to heal her sleep issues.
I began by asking Jennifer what she had already tried. She had tried a wide variety of herbal teas and over-the-counter sleep aids and supplements. Some had some positive benefits for a time, but none had made a sustainable difference in her sleep patterns. She had tried stronger pharmaceutical sleep medications, but was afraid of creating a long-term addiction, and stopped after she ended up feeling dependent on them.
She had also implemented other sleep strategies, such as relaxing reading before bed, no TV at night, keeping the bedroom cool, and taking a warm shower to relax, but none of these had any significant effect.
Her diet consisted of “a lot of salad,” chicken, occasional red meat, and more than a liter of water per day. Her exercise routine consisted of a 20-minute walk per day.
Other health symptoms included headaches (2x/week, throbbing sensation on the temples), occasional migraines, consistently cold hands, and anemia.
The anemia caught my attention, and I asked Jennifer further about this. She reported that she had been a consistent blood donor for the past several years, and felt strongly about donating blood as much as possible. According to a blood test report done by the blood donation center, Jennifer’s hemoglobin levels had fallen slightly below the minimum levels to be allowed to donate blood—that had happened 2 times in the past 3 years. However, in the past 3 months, her blood hemoglobin levels had dropped precipitously, and she was not allowed to donate on her last attempt about a month before coming to see me.
This caught my attention because two of the major causes of insomnia in Chinese medicine fall in the category of Blood Deficiency. Heart Blood Deficiency causes difficulty with falling asleep, and Liver Blood Deficiency causes difficulties with depth of sleep and staying asleep through the night. Jennifer had all of these symptoms. Cold hands, pale facial skin, and orange facial skin coloration are also signs of Blood Deficiency.
However, Blood Deficiency was not the only issue. Jennifer also experienced stress from work, tightness in the upper back and shoulders, throbbing headaches in the temples—all symptoms of Liver Qi Stagnation.
Therefore, the Chinese medicine treatment goal was to nourish the Heart and Liver Blood Deficiency, and release the Liver Qi Stagnation.
For Jennifer’s first acupuncture treatment, I began with the general energy balancing and clearing treatment known as AE (using the acupuncture points Bladder 13, 14, 15, 18, 20 , 23, and Heart 7). I also made the following recommendations:
To nourish Blood Deficiency:
- ¼ pound of red meat per day for 3 months, sourced from a local, organic farm with grass-fed, humanely raised animals
- increased intake of saturated fats from similar farm sources, including eggs, butter, bacon, lard, beef fat, and coconut oil
To release Liver Qi Stagnation:
- 3 days per week of moderately intense cardio. Jennifer chose running.
To improve “sleep hygiene” (these tips all help reduce disruptive stimulation to the mind and body)
- Hide all clocks, to reduce worry over what time is spent awake at night
- Darken the room as much as possible
- Turn off cell phones and all other electronics
- Avoid eating too close to bedtime, but don’t go to sleep too hungry
Second treatment—one week later
Jennifer reported that she woke up half as often each night than she had the preceding week, and that she had experienced no change with falling asleep. She reported that not looking at the clock helped, and she ordered blackout blinds to darken her room at night.
For the acupuncture treatment, I used the Liver Global Balance treatment from Dr. Tan’s Balance Method school of acupuncture. This treatment comprehensively addresses both the Liver and Heart Meridians. The acupuncture points used were Heart 3 and 7, San Jiao 10 and 3, Liver 8 and 3, Gallbladder 34 and 41.
In addition, I added acupuncture points designed to promote sleep and encourage greater emotional peace (An Mian, Shen Men, Yin Tang). I also recommended Suan Zao Ren Tang (with added ingredients), a Chinese herbal medicine formula designed to nourish the Liver Blood, at a dosage of 4 tablets 30 minutes before bed.
Third treatment—one week later
Jennifer reported that the herbs were helping her get to sleep more easily, and that waking up in the middle of the night was still about 50% improved. She was also waking up more easily in the morning, needing less recovery time. I repeated the Liver Global Balance treatment with additional points.
Fourth treatment—one week later
Jennifer reported that, unusually for her, she remembered dreaming, and felt that her sleep was getting deeper. She continued to feel improvements in falling asleep, waking up at night, and waking up in the morning with less lethargy.
I repeated the Liver Global Balance treatment with additional points, and recommended an additional Chinese herbal medicine formula to nourish Heart Blood Deficiency, An Xin Pian (with added ingredients), which is designed to help with falling asleep more easily. I adjusted the dosage of each formula to 2-3 tablets each, 30 minutes before bed.
Fifth treatment—2 weeks later
Jennifer reported that she now was sleeping through the entire night, and the time needed to fall asleep had reduced from the original 60 minutes to 20-30 minutes. She was feeling more lethargic upon waking up, and not wanting to get out of bed. However, in the past week, she had experienced a much higher level of stress than usual from work, due to a personnel shakeup in her office, requiring increased levels of productivity from her during the day.
I asked Jennifer if she had a stress management or meditation method for dealing with stress, and she reported that she didn’t. I introduced the idea of a daily 5 minute meditation practice, and instructed her in the meditation method of allowing all thoughts, emotions and sensations to be just as they are, without making any effort to change them. I also recommended the text True Meditation by Adyshanti, which explains this meditation approach.
I repeated the Liver Global Balance treatment with additional points, and applied lavender essential oil to the points to reduce overall stress, and also to help with the stress-induced headaches that she had been experiencing.
Sixth treatment—one week later
Jennifer reported that she was still sleeping through the night, with occasional dreams, but still took 30 minutes to fall asleep. In the mornings, she had no problems getting up, and during the day, the headaches had completely ceased.
I adjusted her dosage to 3-4 of the An Xin Pian to help with the falling asleep, and 2 of the Suan Zao Ren Tang, 30 minutes before bed. I repeated the Liver Global Balance treatment with additional points.
We also discussed the meditation practice instructions, and clarified the point that in this type of meditation, the goal is not to clear the mind, but rather just to be present to the thoughts and emotions that arise, and allow them to just be as they are, without trying to manipulate them.
Seventh treatment—two weeks later
Jennifer reported that she was now falling asleep in 15-20 minutes, and staying asleep through the night. She was having no problems with waking up, and her energy levels were good throughout the day. Her facial skin tone had brightened, and the orange color underneath the eyes had mostly disappeared. The circulation to her hands had improved, and her headaches were much less frequent. Her eyes were brighter, and she reported that her husband was very happy about how different she was in the mornings.
I repeated the Liver Global Balance treatment with additional points, and we discussed that she would continue the herbs for another 1-2 months, and then take a break.